Welcome to Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub
At Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub, nestled in Appleton, WI, we take pride in delivering a delightful blend of cozy ambiance and high-quality cuisine. Our story began with a passion for crafting exceptional pizza, featuring hand-tossed crusts and a variety of toppings, including our rich Chicago-style stuffed options. Guests rave about our flavorful bruschetta and hearty pasta dishes, all complemented by an inviting drink selection. With a warm atmosphere perfect for any occasion—from date nights to family dinners—Wiseguys is where community meets culinary craftsmanship. Join us for an unforgettable dining experience that keeps our patrons returning for more!
-
1440 Oneida St, Appleton, WI 54915, United States Hotline: +1 920-830-8336
Nestled at 1440 Oneida St in the heart of Appleton, WI, Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub is not just another pizza joint; it's an experience waiting to unfold. With its cozy atmosphere and welcoming vibe, this establishment has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
What sets Wiseguys apart? It’s the combination of quality ingredients, skilled chef craftsmanship, and an extensive menu that caters to every palate. Diners can indulge in delightful starters like Bruschetta—a robust blend of fresh tomatoes, onions, and pesto drizzled with balsamic glaze, or the classic Cheesy Garlic Bread paired with house-made marinara sauce for just $8.13.
The pasta creations, including Fettucini and Spaghetti, allow for customization with various sauces and come with breadsticks, making them perfect for a heartwarming meal after a long day. Priced at an inviting $12.19, these dishes are as comforting as they are satisfying.
Salad lovers won’t be disappointed either. The Boa Salad and the delightful Fedora Salad add a fresh crunch to your meal with choices of creamy dressings that elevate the flavors. The Boa Salad garners praise for its vibrant mix of greens, while the Fedora Salad gets a nod for its crisp iceberg lettuce topped with crunchy toppings.
But let’s get to the star of the show: the pizza. Hand-tossed with the perfect balance of chewiness and crunch, Wiseguys offers both Chicago-style stuffed pizzas and thin crust options loaded with a variety of toppings. Customers rave about the quality, noting the meticulous hands of chefs who bring each pie to life. It's not uncommon to hear praises like “the best pizza I’ve had” from first-time visitors.
The highlight of my visit was undoubtedly the Bruschetta and the delicious hand-tossed pizza, made fresh with zesty homemade sauce that bursts with flavor. Each bite was a revelation, with toppings that danced on the palate. The ambiance, peppered with charming decorations and a dim, cozy lighting, creates an inviting atmosphere perfect for date nights or family dinners.
As diners have shared in enthusiastic reviews, the service is just as commendable. Guests often highlight attentive staff who make you feel right at home. Friendly servers like Rhonda and Addison have left memorable impressions on those looking for a warm dining experience.
Whether you’re seated inside or enjoying a sunny day on the dog-friendly patio, Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub has something for everyone—from craft drinks to delectable fish fry options available on Fridays. If you're in the area and searching for a spot that serves not just pizza but a slice of comfort, look no further than Wiseguys.
- Address: 1440 Oneida St, Appleton, WI 54915
- Phone: +1 920-830-8336
- Must-Try Dishes: Bruschetta, Hand-Tossed Pizza, Pasta Creations
Next time you're craving Italian, give Wiseguys a try—you may just discover your new favorite pizza place.
We've driven past this place so many times and finally decided to give it a try. Atmosphere was outstanding along with the service. The drink selection was good and the food was incredible. If your looking fir a nice cozy pizza place, this is the place to go. We will definitely return.
LOVE this place. Me and my wife’s first time dining here was last night. Great atmosphere inside, and the food was insane. Bruschetta was a contender for the best i’ve ever had. The pizza took a bit to come out but i think the dough and pizza itself is made by hand so i will 100% to receive high quality food. Also Rhonda was one of the best servers we have ever had. We will be back!
Our 1st time Here and the food was awesome A pizza was Delicious My four-year-old daughter got spaghetti And finished before everyone And she said it was super good Full bar Good fish tacos on Friday and all sorts of sandwiches restaurants Atmosphere and decorations are supremely cool The restaurant is dim And I liked it
Good stuffed Chicago style pizza. It does take a while to make it, so if you're really hungry plan on ordering an appetizer. We had garlic bread this time, but we have also enjoyed the mozzarella sticks and split a salad. We went at 5:30 on a Friday and were able to be seated right away. The dining area has always been dark and cozy, but with March Madness going on they were playing basketball on most of the tvs. Like halfway through our meal they turned up the volume so much so that the conversation at our table turned to shouting to be able to hear each other. They have a good drink menu here, and when the weather is nice they have a patio that they allow you to bring your dog to while you eat . Also on Fridays they have fish fry options on the menu as well.
I was looking for some good pizza. I didn't want the cookie cutter chain style pizza. This place is definitely legit. I went with the hand tossed and it did not disappoint. Perfect balance of chewy/crunchy crust. I really enjoyed the cheesy goodness. Keep up the good work. This is definitely my new favorite in the valley.
Had an amazing first experience at Wiseguys Pizzeria. Addison was our server and she made us feel so welcome! Food delicious with a wide selection of gluten free options for myself and low carb options for my wife. This is definitely our new date night spot!
Such a neat and cozy atmosphere. And wonderful food. Whether you’re looking for Chicago style stuffed, or a thinner crust it’s all fantastic. We love the zesty red sauce and with so many topping choices (or specialty pizzas options) it’s always a challenge ordering just one pizza The bruschetta appetizer and Alfredo pasta dish you can tailor to your liking are a couple other of our faves here. One of the best pizza/italian places in the entire Fox Valley.
I’ve been on a quest to try all the pizza in the valley and finally made it into Wiseguys. The pizza was so yummy and I can confidently say Wiseguys is the winner of best pizza I’ve had so far (I’ve tried most in the area!) I highly recommend the hand tossed crust. I got a side of homemade pesto and a side of the zesty sauce-both were so flavorful and good! We were seated immediately and our server was excellent. I can’t wait to come back to get the pesto pasta and try the stuffed pizza!